Blue Tsunami of the 2026 Midterms Was Preceded by a Red Tsunami of 5.6 Million People and $1.5 Trillion in Wealth Leaving Blue States for Red States – NJ Included. Will Gov. Sherrill Be Different?
November 11, 2026We can almost hear NJEA headquarters staff frantically lawyering up after the bombshell revelation: the US Department of Justice and the US Attorney for New Jersey are investigating the NJEA over its unaccounted-for diversion of $45 million of teachers’ dues to back former-President Sean Spiller’s failed run for governor. That’s the upshot from two news stories that emerged over the weekend. First. Politico’s Matt Friedman continues to be the go-to source for breaking news by reporting that the US DOJ and the US Attorney for New Jersey are investigating the NJEA and have sent subpoenas to Working New Jersey, the NJEA-funded, dark-money Super PAC that effectively ran Spiller’s campaign. Then NJ.com reported on Politico‘s story while adding additional details. As both pieces show, Sunlight was right about the Spiller scandal all along, and NJ.com gives Sunlight credit where credit is due. As we documented at the time, Working New Jersey was always an opaque and highly suspect organization run by three former-NJEA execs, which wasted an astounding $40 million of dues on the most expensive primary campaign in New Jersey political history. Working New Jersey’s spending was almost all unaccounted for. Now Working New Jersey has been subpoenaed and there will be an accounting — at least to the Feds. However, we can count on NJEA leadership to continue to stonewall the public and its own members, who also deserve to know the truth. Will the New Jersey press corps don their investigative journalism hats and dig for the truth? We hope they rise to the challenge.
Politico and NJ.com confirm what Sunlight said all along. Over a year ago, Sunlight established the fact-pattern that Politico and NJ.com now confirm and which is the basis for a “perfect storm” of legal actions against the NJEA. Per NJ.com:
In February, NJ.com reported that an analysis by the Sunlight Policy Center of New Jersey — a watchdog organization that has monitored the NJEA for years and is critical of the union — found union leaders directed nearly $45 million in member dues to support Spiller. According to the report, the money was given to the Working New Jersey and Protecting Our Democracy groups.
We encourage everyone to read Sunlight’s reports and draw their own conclusions. Here are the agreed-upon facts:
- Via its own SuperPAC, Garden State Forward, NJEA leadership (including the conflicted Sean Spiller) funneled $5 million of dues to dark-money SuperPAC Protecting our Democracy and another $39.9 million to dark-money SuperPAC Working New Jersey, for a total of $44.9 million — all to back Spiller’s run. It was the most expensive primary campaign in New Jersey history.
- Spiller and NJEA leadership out-sourced Spiller’s campaign to Working New Jersey, which spent $39.7 million — or 99% of the total — because Spiller’s campaign only raised and spent $454,512.
- Working New Jersey was run by three former-NJEA execs: Ed Richardson, Steve Wollmer, and Gayl Sheppard.
- The NJEA SuperPAC, Garden State Forward, was and is funded entirely by teachers’ regular, annual dues (not separate, voluntary contributions to NJEA PAC).
- The NJEA and Spiller were sued by two teachers for spending their annual dues on politics without their knowledge or consent.
- As a result of the Spiller scandal, the NJEA has a “chilly” (Politico), “strained” (NJ.com) relationship with Gov. Sherrill. This has degraded the NJEA’s influence over several important policy issues and adds to the overall cost to members of the Spiller scandal.
- There are now federal investigations of the NJEA by both the DOJ and the US Attorney for New Jersey over the Spiller scandal, with several subpoenas issued to Working New Jersey.
The NJEA is in serious legal hot water and incurring millions in legal fees. The DOJ investigation and the lawsuit are just two of several legal challenges the NJEA is facing in the aftermath of the Spiller scandal. New Jersey Policy Institute filed a complaint with the IRS, alleging that all the $120 million spent by Garden State Forward since 2013 was not reported as the political spending it was, as well as a complaint with the New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission, both of which are pending. We can only imagine the lawyering-up currently going on at NJEA headquarters and hope the NJEA will report what its legal expenses amount to because members need to know that it’s not just the $45 million of their dues that were wasted; the NJEA will now incur many millions in legal fees to defend against this “perfect storm” of legal actions. All because of the Spiller scandal.
NJEA leadership continues to stonewall its own members and everyone else. Incredibly, the NJEA has still not told its members the truth about the Spiller scandal. A courageous teacher messaged Sunlight that he had asked the four candidates currently competing for NJEA vice president and secretary-treasurer (Petal Robertson, Tina Dare, Joe Toma, and Angela DeLuccia) the 17 questions (including several about the Spiller scandal) that Sunlight urged teachers to ask the candidates at the NJEA convention. Only two of the four responded at all and none answered a single question. NJEA leadership has also been completely opaque about the federal investigations and only acknowledged them to NJ.com because of the leak to Politico. Otherwise, they would have been completely silent and, once again, members as well as the public would be kept in the dark.
The New Jersey public deserves the truth and the press corps should provide it. The NJEA is the “most politically powerful public sector union” in New Jersey (Politico) and “a major force” in New Jersey politics (NJ.com). What the NJEA does or does not do matters to its members as well as to the state. Both NJEA members and the general public deserve as much information as can be gathered about the NJEA’s legal troubles and potential legal jeopardy. NJEA leadership has shown it has no interest in providing any information to anyone, including its own members. Might this be an opportunity for the New Jersey press corps to don their investigative journalism hats and dig up some facts? We hope they rise to the challenge.
